Verified Voting Blog: Verified Voting Letter to Tennessee State Senators

We respectfully urge you to vote No on House Bill 614, which seeks to delay implementation of the Tennessee Voter Confidence Act and fatally weaken its provision for manual post-election audits of electronic vote tallies. HB 614 is on the Senate's calendar for Tuesday January 12, 2010. Rejection of the bill is warranted based on the determination of the Chancery Court regarding the TVCA and its requirements for federal certification of voting systems, and on the State's still un-met need for verifiable ballots and hand-counted audits of electronic vote tallies.

In November 2009, the Chancery Court of Davidson County, after receiving information from voting technology experts, corrected the assumption that the TVCA required new voting systems to be certified by the United States Election Assistance Commission (the EAC) to the 2005 version of the Federal voluntary voting system guidelines. The Court issued a Conclusion of Law noting the TVCA allows voting systems to be certified by the EAC to either the 2002 voting system standards or the 2005 guidelines, and ordered the State Elections Division to proceed with implementation without delay.

The Voting News Daily: Delayed – Tennessee paper ballot law, GA SOS hopeful blasts state undercounts

The US Dept of Justice readies lawsuit to undo voting machine merger…Libertarian candidate for Georgia SOS blasts Diebold machines and state-wide vote undercounts…Votes and Doubts in Detroit….Bill to Delay Tennessee Voter Confidence Act until 2012 Passes……Please check out the “Universal” Ballot Counter by Mitch Trachtenberg…For sale on Internet – Ukraine’s election votes…

All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CO: How Aspen Violated Colorado Ranked Choice Voting Rules
http://aspenelectionreview.blogspot.com/2010/01/how-aspen-violated-colorado-ranked.html
[Mike LaBonte, an election quality advocate from Massachusetts posted the following summary of one portion of his work related to the Aspen election…

GA: Libertarian Secretary of State Candidate David Chastain Blasts Georgia’s Infamous Diebold Electronic Voting Machines
http://bludgeonandskewer.blogspot.com/2010/01/libertarian-secretary-of-state.html
So it looks like our good old Diebold’s are dropping votes. Lots of votes. Which is a rotten shame considering that the votes were cast by citizens who went to the polls in good faith to perform their civic duty.

GA: SOS candidate informs Cobb group of state-wide vote undercounts
http://www.theweekly.com/news/2010/January/11/David_Chastain.html
…In December, Chastain spent a day in the research room of the State Archives studying election records from county referendums around Georgia. He focused on single-issue referendums where there is only one question on the ballot

IL: Voters will find fewer polling places as funds, judges become scarce
http://bit.ly/6yDcsm
January 10, 2010 DECATUR – Voters are going to be casting their ballots at a smaller number of polling locations, starting with the February primary election, Macon County Clerk Steve Bean said.
MI: Votes and doubts
http://metrotimes.com/news/story.asp?id=14701
Barrow demands recounts, then an investigation. Here’s why.
Asserting that “probable cause exists” to believe that a criminal conspiracy involving “vote tampering, ballot box stuffing and electronic vote manipulation” occurred, Barrow has asked authorities at every level to investigate. Among those sent the complaint were state Attorney General Mike Cox, Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy, Secretary of State Terri Lynn Land, U.S. Attorney Barbara McQuade and the Civil Rights Division of the U.S. Department of Justice.

NJ: Essex County elections chief back to work after being charged in employee pay scheme
http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2010/01/essex_county_elections_chief_b.html
January 11, 2010 NEWARK — Carmine Casciano, the veteran Essex County superintendent of elections, was back on the job today, just days after he was charged with official misconduct in a scheme to give paid days off to employees who worked on political campaigns.

TN: Bill to Delay Tennessee Voter Confidence Act Passes
http://www.liberadio.com/2010/01/12/bill-to-delay-tennessee-voter-confidence-act-passes/
The bill to delay the Tennessee Voter Confidence Act passes (mostly along party lines) in the Senate, 22-10. It now goes to the Governor for his signature…

TN: Republicans Delay Voter Confidence Act
http://blogs.nashvillescene.com/pitw/2010/01/senate_votes_to_delay_voter_co.php
…the Senate voted 22-10 to delay implementation of the Tennessee Voter Confidence Act until the 2012 elections.

With great fanfare, Republicans and Democrats alike embraced this law in 2008 to eliminate the hazards of paperless, unverified electronic voting.

TN: What Would Jesus Do If He Were a Tennessee State Senator?
http://blogs.nashvillescene.com/pitw/2010/01/what_would_jesus_do_if_he_were.php
There is only one correct, moral, patriotic decision left to make. That is to keep the Voter Confidence Act intact and on-track for 2010.

The Voting News Daily: Just say no to Internet Voting, DoJ Voting Rights Fight Reboots, Absentee voting growth market for fraud?

DoJ Voting Rights Fight Reboots…LTE: Just say no to Internet Voting – “as a programmer, I must caution you. Not only do programmers make mistakes, some of them can be bought.” Lisa Pease, electronic voting activist…Hawaii lacks funds to send Rep. to Congress…“Absentee voting is the new growth market for election fraud,” said Richard Hayes-Phillips -responding to news of the Detroit recount…Vote Fraud charges in Independence Louisiana….Tennessee is Poised to Move Backwards Again due SB0872 – the bill that if passed would delay implementation of the Tennessee Voter Confidence Act (TVCA) until 2012…Overseas military will have to register again to get ballots this year…

All this and more in today’s voting news below…

CA: Party pays thousands to signature collector at center of past controversies
http://bit.ly/93aRti
…In 2006, Burkett’s firm was hit by voter-registration fraud allegations in Orange and San Bernardino counties.

Dozens of voters claimed their party affiliation had been switched to Republican without their knowledge by signature collectors working for Burkett.

HI: Hawaii lacks funds to send Rep. to Congress
http://www.presstv.ir/detail.aspx?id=115825§ionid=3510203
A vote-by-mail special election scheduled for May 1 could only be held if the state collected the USD 925,000 it would cost. This is while a walk-in election would mean 1.2 million for the election office coffer.

IL: Election law angers county clerk (machines would beep)
http://bit.ly/4uUb8v
McHenry County Clerk Katherine Schultz has told the state that she will not comply with a controversial election “undervoting” law for the Feb. 2 primary.

Lake County’s voting machine software is able to accommodate the new law, County Clerk Willard Helander said. But she called the law flawed and unnecessary and said it could mislead people who chose not to vote for a statewide candidate to think that they made a mistake.

“[The General Assembly] didn’t seem to care if you skip voting for Congress, County Board or sheriff, so there’s no equal protection. It seems to be a very flawed law. It’s Illinois at work,” Helander said.

LA: Voter fraud charges causing change in Independence police dept.*
http://www.wwltv.com/news/Voter-fraud-charges-causing-change-in-Independence-police-dept-81182412.html
January 11, 2010 …Maurer was elected Police Chief in February 2008, but is now being charged in a Federal Bill of Information with illegally registering voters for that election.

“A number of people from the Town of Independence called and came in,” Tony Radosti, the Vice-President of the Metropolitan Crime Commission told Eyewitness News Monday. “They were telling us about people being registered to vote in the city who were not residents.”

MI: Voter fraud in Detroit?
http://bit.ly/8Ajkug
DETROIT — Former mayoral candidate Tom Barrow is waging a battle to expose what he and others call massive, historic election fraud in last November’s mayoral race. Over 51 percent of the votes cast were compromised, Barrow charges, including all 41,458 absentee ballots deemed unrecountable by the Wayne County Board of Canvassers last month.

BenDor said elections in counties across the state are rife with absentee voter fraud, insecure chains of custody of paper ballots, and other irregularities…

NY: First Look at NY’s New Electronic Voting Machines (video)
http://www.nbcnewyork.com/station/as-seen-on/First_Look_at_NY_s_New_Electronic_Voting_Machines_New_York.html

Verified Voting Blog: Justice Department Seeks to Block Merger of Voting Machine Vendors

According to an article in the New York Post a lawsuit is expected to be filed by the Department of Justice that would seek to block the already-completed merger of the nation's two largest voting-machine makers, Election Systems & Software (ES&S) and Premier Election Solutions (formerly Diebold Election Systems). The article cites “a person close to the situation” that the DoJ lawsuit, “if successful, would effectively undo the merger of Diebold's Premier Elections Solutions with Election Systems & Software, a $5 million deal completed in September.”

The Voting News Daily: ES&S wins NYC bid, Lobbyist indicted, The Limitations of Paper Ballots and Recounts

Editor note: our apologies, voting news was not published yesterday due to incidents out of our control. Normally you can expect voting news to be published 5 days a week. Thank you for your patience.
New study asks: “Burning question for California: Was Prop 8 Straight”…Ballot-look-alike mail stirs up controversy in Oregon…I guess they couldn’t afford a stamp? Nearly all Oregon governor hopefuls have skipped voting. Only former secretary of state is a consistent voter…

Department of Defense has started training thousands to help millions register to vote…Some military internet voting experiments on the horizon even though experts say there are too many issues with internet voting…..

Ten Virginia civil-rights and faith-based groups address Virginia’s Governor:
“Gov. Kaine has the opportunity to make history and reverse one of the last vestiges of Jim Crow segregation. It is time Virginia joins the ranks of the 48 other states who restore voting rights for former felons when they have paid their debt to society.”

CA: Was Pro 8 Straight?
http://www.wasprop8straight.org/index.html
Election Watchdogs and GLBT Rights Groups Call For Investigation!

CO: Bar association weighs in on Worcester-Election Commission conflict
http://www.aspendailynews.com/section/home/138642

HI: Mail-in ballot might boost special election turnout
http://www.starbulletin.com/editorials/20100106_Mail-in_ballot_might_boost_special_election_turnout.html

IN: Bill would allow voters to cast ballot by mail without excuse
http://www.fox59.com/news/sns-ap-in-xgr–votebymail,0,2884850.story

KS: Grant pays for new ballot-counting machines in Cherokee County
http://www.joplinglobe.com/local/local_story_007212836.html
COLUMBUS, Kan. — New ballot-counting machines will be in place for April city elections in Cherokee County, because of a $17,388 federal grant.

MI: Detroit: The Limitations of Paper Ballots and Recounts
http://www.ctvoterscount.org/?p=2753
January 7, 2010 The value of paper ballots and recounts depends on the chain-of-custody and the integrity of election officials. Bev Harris reports in a letter the almost unbelievable, sad situation in a Detroit Mayoral race recount..

MI: Michigan clerks back online registration
http://www.hometownlife.com/article/20100107/NEWS15/1070604
Jan 08, 2010 – With so much of every-day life centering around the computer these days, local clerks are by and large in favor of legislation that would allow residents to use the computer to register to vote. Brad Kadrich, Observer & Eccentric.

MT: Citizens United and Montana corruption through history
http://politicalactivitylaw.com/?p=7184
January 8, 2010 The Flathead Beacon has it all this morning for history buffs in this article about Citizens United: a copper magnate, 1912 elections, and bribing state legislators for their votes in a senate election

NM: Some Anthony residents experience voting problems; election otherwise going
http://www.lcsun-news.com/las_cruces-news/ci_14127150
01/05/2010 ANTHONY, N.M. — Some Anthony residents trying to vote in the community’s incorporation election today are being turned away because they don’t live in the boundaries of the proposed new city —a requirement to vote.

“We’re getting quite a few of those,” said Doña Ana County Clerk Lynn Ellins. “These are people with an Anthony address but don’t live within the area proposed for incorporation.”

NY: A Day Late… » *
http://www.nydailynews.com/blogs/dailypolitics/2010/01/a-day-late.html
January 6, 2010 One day after the Board of Elections commissioners awarded Election Systems and Software of Omaha a multimillion-dollar contract to provide the city with new electronic voting machines, US Attorney Preet Bharara has indicted one of the firm’s lobbyists on corruption charges.

Verified Voting Blog: Monopoly, ES&S, and Nassau County

There was lots of reporting last week about the decision to award New York City’s huge voting machine contract to the ES&S, but the really interesting story slipped by nearly unnoticed – Nassau County, home to nearly 1 million registered voters, announced they were abandoning their recently purchased Dominion ImageCast machines for ES&S systems. This announcement came as quite a surprise because Nassau County has been using the Dominion machines for accessible voting in all polling places since 2008, as well as spent time and money training poll workers in the use of the new systems. So how is it that ES&S managed to snatch away Nassau County, in terms of voting system sales the second largest prize in New York State, from the much smaller Dominion? The answer is a cautionary tale about the power of a near monopoly to force smaller competitors out of the market.

ES&S has long been one of a handful of voting machine companies dominating the United States market. But recently, with Sequoia Voting Systems struggling financially, and the absorption of Diebold into ES&S (a move opposed by many), the company already has a near-stranglehold on providing voting systems and services to election officials. In New York State however, ES&S faces a small competitor from just across Lake Ontario in Canada, Dominion Voting. Dominion designed and built the ImageCast, a new scanner and accessible ballot marker combination system that many County Boards of Elections around the state, including Nassau, liked enough to order and use in 2008 and 2009 [Note - initially Dominion partnered with Sequoia to bring the ImageCast to New York, but Sequoia later pulled out and turned the contract over to Dominion]. Indeed, even if New York City chose the ES&S DS200 scanner, a decision finally made this week, little upstart Dominion would still have provided over half of the Empire State’s huge number of voting machines! But big companies like Wal-Mart and ES&S don’t stand around idly letting small competitors take what they see as their market share. And the way they do it is by being big enough to offer customers deals that are simply too good to pass up. And that’s exactly what ES&S did in Nassau County.

The Voting News Daily: MN Court makes 2008 absentee ballots public, Michigan voters wrongly purged?

A MN Court says the public may view 2008 absentee ballots…With a 94% cut in its budget, Hawaii’s Office of Elections can’t pay for any election in 2010…
Do Voters Deserve Same Protections As Small Businesses, Schools, and Non-Profits?….Barrow asks Michigan Attorney Gen to investigate alleged voter fraud in Detroit…Paul Gronke finds “Even MORE on newspaper registration forms??”…


All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CA: Instant-runoff voting a go for Oakland
http://www.insidebayarea.com/oaklandtribune/localnews/ci_14132699
01/06/2010…There will be an upfront cost: the county says it will charge up to $1.5 million to pay for voter education and equipment upgrades to launch instant-runoff voting in Oakland, Berkeley and San Leandro.

CA: Bloggers come out swinging for IRV
http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/blogs/inoakland/detail?&entry_id=54632

CT: Do Voters Deserve Same Protections As Small Businesses, Schools, and Non-Profits?
http://www.ctvoterscount.org/?p=2748
The American Bankers Association has issued guidelines that small businesses should use separate computers for banking transactions to avoid viruses that can steal funds.

HI: Constitutional amendment sought to establish secretary of state in Hawaii
http://bit.ly/6UeP5A
Jan 06, 2010 – Lt. Gov. James “Duke” Aiona said today that he would propose a constitutional amendment to establish an independent, elected Secretary of State to administer elections. The Secretary of State would replace the state Elections Commission and the chief elections officer

HI: Hearing shows Hawaii special election funding is still in limbo
http://disappearednews.com/2010/01/hearing-shows-hawaii-special-election.html
…Now it has an additional challenge since Congressman Neil Abercrombie announced he will resign to run for governor on February 28…

Much more important is what happens when the Chief Elections Officer does issue the writ of election. Whether the election takes place by mail or in traditional polling places, it can’t be paid for by IOUs.

IL: Champaign County Clerk – Taking the Job Seriously
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2010/01/05/taking-the-job-seriously/
In the bustle of election day, mistakes can happen. Every election we try to do more to prevent those mistakes. The number of judges going through training should give every voter confidence that their election judges are doing their best to bring them a fair, honest, and efficient election day.

MA: Concerns over measure to let Bay State voters register on Election Day
http://www.lowellsun.com/todaysheadlines/ci_14118454
01/04/2010 BOSTON — Supporters of a bill to allow Massachusetts voters to register on Election Day say it will improve citizen participation as it has in nine states that allow the system.

Barnstable Town Clerk Linda Hutchenrider says the trade-off between provisional ballots and same-day registration makes the proposed law change worthwhile.

“Instead of there being a great confusion and individuals needing a provisional ballot and signing 75 sheets, let them just fill out the card, vote and that’s it,” she said.

MI: Barrow asks Cox to investigate alleged voter fraud in Detroit
http://www.detnews.com/article/20100106/METRO/1060407/1361/Barrow-asks-Cox-to-investigate-alleged-voter-fraud-in-Detroit
Jan 6, 2009. Detroit — The man who lost to Dave Bing in November’s mayoral election today asked Michigan’s Attorney General for a criminal investigation of what he claims is evidence of massive ballot tampering and a conspiracy to cover-up the manipulation.

Tom Barrow earlier this month called for the Detroit Election Board to resign and a full investigation launched after the Wayne County Board of Canvassers ruled none of the 41,485 absentee ballots cast in the Nov.

The Voting News Daily: Vote fixing charges in Clay Co. KY, Washington ends ban on felon voting

Federal Prosecutors: Kentucky Officials Manipulated Clay County Elections for Decades …Barrow seeks investigation into handling of Detroit election…Nassau (NY) switches vote-machine contractors… 9th Circuit throws out Wash. ban on felon voting…New Year’s resolution: Register to vote (or update your registration)…. Brad Friedman of Bradblog visits former Diebold now ES&S HQ in Texas and finds that “the new boss…same as the old boss”…

All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CA: EDA Study Shows 2008 CA Prop 8 Results Appear to Have Been Corrupted
http://electiondefensealliance.org/CA-Prop-8-Corrupted

CA: Dear Council: 64,000 voters are the boss of you. You have to do IRV.
http://www.abetteroakland.com/dear-council-64000-voters-are-the-boss-of-you-you-have-to-do-irv/2010-01-05

You don’t get a pass on ignoring voter mandates just because you don’t like them, and you don’t get a pass because you have a budget crisis either, and Oakland residents should contact their Councilmembers today, or come to the meeting tonight

FL: Palm Beach County’s new election costs rile city leaders
http://www.sun-sentinel.com/news/palm-beach/fl-bucher-cities-election-cost-20100104,0,439206.story
Jan 05, 2010 – An agreement between Supervisor of Elections Susan Bucher and most of Palm Beach County’s 38 communities has some local leaders watching their wallets as the March 9 municipal elections approach. Some city leaders question whether the new arrangement is fair for their residents. Jason Schultz, Sun-Sentinel

GA: Cole pulls name from secretary of state appointment
http://www.macon.com/local/story/973587.html
Jan 05, 2010 – State Rep. Jim Cole of Forsyth won’t be Georgia’s next secretary of state after all.

HI: May 1 is earliest Hawaii could hold special election for Abercrombie’s seat
http://bit.ly/8WH22m
…Scott Nago, the interim chief elections officer, told the state Senate Ways and Means Committee that his preference would be to hold an all mail special election with some walk-in voting sites.

He estimated that the cost of an all mail special election would be $925,000. A traditional special election with polling places would cost about $1.2 million.

IL: Clerks concerned about voting law
http://www.reviewatlas.com/news/x1437802188/Clerks-concerned-about-voting-law
MONMOUTH — Many Illinois voters, including those in Warren County, will be asked to be a little more patient when heading to the polls this year.

That’s because — thanks to a provision passed by the Illinois State Legislature and signed into law by then-Gov. Rod Blagojevich in 2007 — if a voter fails to vote for any particular office, many voting machines will beep loudly and spit the ballot back out. An election judge will then have to assist the voter, either correcting the undervote or overriding the system and casting the vote with the omission

KY: Federal Prosecutors: Kentucky Officials Manipulated Clay County Elections for Decades
http://www.bradblog.com/?p=7627

MI: BARROW SEEKS INVESTIGATION INTO HANDLING OF ELECTION
http://metrotimes.com/blog/newsblawg.asp?perm=952
Tom Barrow, who lost to Dave Bing in the Nov. 3 Detroit mayoral election, has sent letters to a variety of public officials — ranging from Michigan Attorney General Mike Cox and Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy to the FBI and U.S. Department of Justice — seeking a criminal investigation into the way the contest was handled.

In his letter, Barrow alleges that there is probable cause to believe that “vote tampering, ballot box stuffing and electronic vote manipulation” occurred.

The Voting News Daily: Vote-machine lobbyist was in ‘rig’ trouble, NY City giving up levers, Same Day Registration pros and cons

In New York we learn that one vendor’s lobbyist was involved in a vote rigging scandal. Meanwhile one vendor claims they will provide more jobs than the other vendor…. Massachusetts weighs the pros and cons of same day registration….Oregon is considering adopting online voter registration..

All this and more in today’s voting news below…

CA: Ranked Choice Voting May Cost Oakland $947,000
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/92510/archives/2010/01/04/ranked-choice-voting-may-cost-oakland-947000
Mon, Jan 4, 2010…However, the city’s costs could increase to a maximum
of $1.5 million (not including the savings of not having a June
election) if either or both Berkeley and San Leandro decide to forgo
ranked choice voting this year

MA: Same-day voter registration proposal has pros and cons
http://www.dailynewstribune.com/homepage/x1444028251/Same-day-voter-registration-proposal-has-pros-and-cons
Jan 02, 2010 Supporters of a bill to allow voters to register on Election Day say it will improve citizen participation in democracy as it has in nine states that allow the system. But some municipal officials and the secretary of state worry about the cost and potential confusion of such a system.

Langenburg said that in the past, additional polling workers were hired to handle provisional ballots. Those workers now are responsible for same-day registration forms. The cost of printing the forms is covered by what they used to spend on provisional ballots.

What the Mass. Freedom to Vote Act would do
http://www.lowellsun.com/todaysheadlines/ci_14118453

MI: Are These The Waning Days of ‘Austin v Michigan Chamber of Commerce’
http://bit.ly/6pU8rI (podcast available) Michigan Chamber of Commerce VP Bob LaBrandt holds a copy of the newspaper ad that served as the basis of the legal case Austin vs Michigan Chamber of Commerce

MI: Online Voting Bill Heads to State Senate
http://new.wkzo.com/news/articles/2010/jan/04/online-voting-bill-heads-state-senate/
January 4, 2010 Just two states allow residents to register to vote online, but Michigan could be on the verge of being the third to embrace the technology

NH: New Hampshire Ballot Access Bills Get Hearing Date
http://www.ballot-access.org/2010/01/04/new-hampshire-ballot-access-bills-get-hearing-date/

NY: Vote-machine lobbyist was in ‘rig’ trouble
http://bit.ly/8ypLLv

January 4, 2010 A lobbyist working for the company believed to have the edge to win a multimillion-dollar contract to replace the city’s lever-operated voting machines was once embroiled in a flap over ballot fixing

Anthony Mangone, a Westchester-based lawyer and lobbyist hired to help Election Systems & Software, testified that he tampered with ballots in a voting-fraud criminal case against a political operative working for then-state Sen. Nicholas Spano (R-Westchester) in 2002.

NY: City Finally Poised to Give Up Lever Voting Machines
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/04/nyregion/04machines.html
January 3, 2010 …After years of delays and missteps, the city’s Board of Elections is expected to choose new electronic voting machines on Tuesday that will be rolled out in time for the September primary. In so doing, New York City will become one of the last places in the country to get rid of its lever-operated voting machines.

NY: Company says New York jobs riding on voting-machine contract
http://www.theithacajournal.com/article/20100104/NEWS01/1040327/Company+says+New+York+jobs+riding+on+voting-machine+contract
January 4, 2010 ALBANY — As New York City prepares to choose a voting-machine system Tuesday, one of two companies vying for the contract says winning it would mean more jobs for New Yorkers, particularly in the Rochester and Southern Tier regions.

The Voting News Daily: Military voting rights, Aspen’s bad example, Secret ballot waiver

Good by 2009, hello 2010! Happy new year! Best wishes to all readers.

In Georgia, “Group calls on Perdue to appoint independent as interim Secretary of State”…New York Daily News reports on $ spent by voting vendors: Dominion spent $64,000 this year and ES&S has spent $193,000…

It almost didn’t happen: The Department of Defense will act as a voter registration agency thanks to some major arm twisting. Stars and Stripe reports – “That’s a big deal, and not just for military voting rights. Earlier this year Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, placed a hold on the president’s nomination for under secretary of defense for personnel and readiness (Clifford Stanley) until the issue was resolved.”

Secret ballot waiver: Take a look at a fax ballot form from Marion Co. Oregon. The voter must sign a waiver giving up the right to a secret ballot….

Is internet voting a good idea? Verified Voting’s statement on internet voting at their website. What could go wrong? Read Wired News article “The Decade’s 10 Most Dastardly Cybercrimes” and then think about it.

All this and more in today’s voting news below…

AZ: Counties, supervisors sued over Diebold voting machines
http://bit.ly/6JCNYh
12/29/2009 …The controversy stems from the computer touch-screen machines that have become prevalent throughout the country.

Four Arizona residents, backed by the group Voter Action, a non-profit advocacy group, filed a lawsuit in 2006 against then Secretary of State Jan Brewer and 13 of the 15 county election officers. That suit is still ongoing and now county supervisors are individually named in the suit.

CA: Long Beach school board election had only 6 percent turnout
http://www.presstelegram.com/news/ci_14096499?source=rss
12/30/2009 LONG BEACH – Tuesday’s school board election – wedged between the Christmas and New Year’s weekends – resulted in the lowest voter turnout in recent Long Beach history, City Clerk Larry Herrera said Wednesday.

Herrera noted that 77 percent of the ballots were sent in by mail.

CA: California Voter Foundation Releases Study of What Information States Ask For on Voter Registration Forms
http://www.ballot-access.org/2009/12/31/california-voter-releases-study-of-what-information-states-ask-for-on-voter-registration-forms/

CO: Aspen’s bad example (LTE)
http://bit.ly/4H5kQk
…Transparency in elections is the foundation to our democracy. The recent withholding of ballot images from the public, after they had been displayed publicly, does the Aspen community great harm.

GA: Group calls on Perdue to appoint independent as interim Secretary of State
http://www.peachpundit.com/2009/12/30/group-calls-on-perdue-to-appoint-independent-as-interim-secretary-of-state/
December 30, 2009… The group, Voters Organized for Trusted Election Results in Georgia, is a diverse, non-partisan, technology neutral, coalition of Georgia voters and organizations. They contend that the new secretary “should be independent of both major political parties” and “have no direct or indirect ties with the voting machine vendor lobbyist, Massey and Bowers.”

NY: How political lobbyists are rocking the vote in New York City
http://www.nydailynews.com/opinions/2009/12/31/2009-12-31_how_lobbyists_are_rocking_the_vote_in_ny.html
December 31st 2009 …Each firm has spent lavishly on lobbyists. Dominion has paid $64,000 this year to Stanley Schlein, an ex-chairman of the Civil Service Commission with a client list that includes top Bronx Democrats. ES&S has spent $193,000 on a bevy of lobbyists including Hank Sheinkopf, Norman Levy and powerhouse firm Davidoff, Malito & Hutcher.

The Voting News Daily: Kanawha Co WV considers military internet vote, Philippines gets voting machines from China

As we post the news on the last day of year 2009, we take a moment to honor John Gideon (1947-2009), the editor of the original “Daily Voting News”. John founded the “Daily Voting News” February 6, 2004 . John’s tireless work brought increased awareness of voting machine problems around the country. The “DVN” was a must read for citizens, voting activists, advocacy groups and public officials. During these past 5 years, state after state abandon paperless voting. On New Years eve, this edition of Voting News is dedicated to John Gideon.

The news includes a fascinating interview with Lisa Burks of Arkansas who remembers an election meltdown so bad in Arkansas that “they were voting on paper towels & on hoods of cars….”…

Experimenting with the military vote: Kanawha Co. WVa to consider Internet voting for military. BUT: “if we acknowledge that voting systems connected to the Internet are inherently insecure, how is it that we can even consider online voting systems which have the Internet at their core?” ~ Bo Lipari, Verified Voting Researcher….Pentagon Discuses Servicemember Voting Laws Changes…

All this and more in today’s voting news below…

AR: Interview With Lisa Burks (voting activist who led push for paper ballots)
http://bluearkansas.blogspot.com/2009/12/interview-with-lisa-burks.html
…The problems were too numerous for this article, to name a few; from electronic ballot cartridges not arriving in time to begin early voting, (the cartridges boot up the machines. load the election information on the screens, have the election information programmed into them, store the vote totals afterwards until they are downloaded to the software to be transmitted via the internet to the SOS office) to election totals being placed in the software and being ‘scrambled’, to voters & candidates touching the screens to vote for their candidate then seeing their vote flip to a different candidate, to the election workers not being able to shut the machines down as the clocks were incorrectly set. If you can’t shut them down, you can vote on them all night. It was so bad in Phillips County, they closed the polls down and put a sign on the door. In another AR county they were voting on paper towels & on hoods of cars….

CO: Aspen Election Review: Response to Mike LeBonte
http://www.aspentovail.com/2009/12/aspen-election-review-response-to-mike-lebonte/
December 30, 2009 Interpreted contents of each ballot, scanned by True Ballot, were publicly released. Open records requests for a CD of image scans were denied. Aspen has been sued to protect records from destruction and to allow inspection of the …

CO: YouTube – ASPENISTAN MAYOR HOLDS ASPEN BALLOTS HOSTAGE PT 2 (satire)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HCoveBPmm7c
Was the Aspen city election commission illegally dismissed for questioning election irregularities in a recent municipal election?

FL: Former supervisor of elections writing a book
http://www.wpbf.com/news/22092761/detail.html
Dec 31, 2009 – A former Palm Beach County Supervisor of Elections is telling her side of the Butterfly Ballot story in a book. Theresa LePore is still working on the finishing touches of her book but she hopes the it will set the record straight.

The Voting News Daily: Florida's rules leave too many voteless, End Judicial selection by election? Role of Twitter in Iran 2008 election

Florida rules leave too many voteless. FL’s “no match no vote” rule allows clerical errors to disenfranchise voters….Open source voting machines—an opportunity for Hawaii…Want to know about problems with Voting By Mail?…Money in politics? Congressional candidates raised $1.42 BILLION IN 2007-2008…The Role of Twitter in the Iran Elections of 2009

All this and more in the voting news below….

CO: LTE. Is IRV too complicated?
http://bit.ly/6rxnC5
…The May 5 election night video and written material found online raise some questions. Considering the apparent missteps and controversy surrounding that election, will Aspen continue to use IRV for future mayoral and City Council elections? If so, will private contractors again be brought in to conduct the elections?

FL: Florida rules leave too many voteless
http://www.tampabay.com/opinion/editorials/florida-rules-leave-too-many-voteless/1059886
Sunday, December 20, 2009 …Florida’s “No Match, No Vote” law denies voter registration to any applicant whose registration form doesn’t match either the Social Security or Florida’s driver’s license databases. Sometimes it’s a bureaucratic error that causes the problem. Sometimes voters transpose a number or list a nickname. But last year, results showed the stringent requirement disproportionately impacted Hispanics and African-Americans seeking to register in Florida. Unless they took the time and effort to follow up after being notified of the problem, they couldn’t vote or else cast a provisional ballot that was later rejected.

FL: Collier, Lee counties helping state restore voting rights to felons
http://www.naplesnews.com/news/2009/dec/29/collier-lee-counties-helping-state-restore-voting-/
December 29, 2009 The initiative is in response to an August 2008 executive order from Florida Gov. Charlie Crist so the state can speed up restoration of civil rights, including the right to vote.

For more information about the program, go to www.FLRestoreMyRights.com

FL: Supervisor Of Election’s Facebook Hacked
http://www.news4jax.com/news/22082964/detail.html
Jerry Holland Says E-Mail Sent Leading People To Virus

GA: Georgia VoteSafe gets OK
Dec 29, 2009 News release from the Secretary of State’s Office
http://www.walb.com/Global/story.asp?S=11743662
…The Georgia VoteSafe Program provides for the confidentiality of residence address of certain registered voters who have been, or may be, subject to acts of family violence, stalking or currently reside in a family violence shelter.

HI: Open source voting machines—an opportunity for Hawaii
http://disappearednews.com/2009/12/open-source-voting-machinesan.html
Hawaii could save money, create jobs, recycle many old computers, and protect the integrity of its vote by choosing to participate in an open-source voting project. I’ve mentioned this before, but this time there are details.

HI: Panel picks interim chief elections officer
http://www.starbulletin.com/news/breaking/80362412.html
Scott Nago has been with the Office of Elections since 1997
The state Elections Commission this morning chose Scott Nago as the interim chief elections officer, replacing Kevin Cronin, who abruptly resigned early this month.

ID: Man admits to voting twice *
http://www.mtexpress.com/index2.php?ID=2005129395
The Blaine County Prosecuting Attorney’s Office had alleged that Coiner voted in 2008by absentee ballot in Twin Falls County and again in person in Blaine County.

After Coiner pleaded guilty, Judge Jason Walker sentenced him to one-year unsupervised probation and 40 hours community service. Coiner was also fined $300 plus $75 court costs. The crime of “attempting to vote when not qualified” is punishable in Idaho by up to six months in jail.

The Voting News Daily: Maryland eyes paper voting, OH considers voting bill, MO considers early voting

“Bad Business” says Florida paper about ES&S/Diebold voting machine monopoly…New York voter surprised to hear that election clerk declared him deceased….In Maryland “Will state pull the plug on new voting machines?”…Legislation filed for early voting in Missouri, 30 other states already have early voting…Ohio legislators consider Senate Bill 8 which would impact voter registration, early voting and voter rolls….Good idea? WV approves military internet vote proposal. Meanwhile Hackers Steal South Korean War Plans…

All this and more in today’s voting news below…

FL: Editorial: Bad business
http://www.gainesville.com/article/20091227/OPINION01/912271000/1017
December 27, 2009 Corporate mergers can be good for business. But if mergers lead to less competition and innovation, they are not necessarily good for consumers.

This is especially true when the “consumers” are voters and the product voting machines.

IL: State Eases Absentee Voting Laws
http://illinoishomepage.net/content/fulltext/?cid=124792

IL: New state law puts crimp in secret ballot
http://www.myjournalcourier.com/news/law-24877-state-ballot.html
December 21, 2009 State Sen. William R. Haine said he is working to counter the effect of a new state law that some county clerks say thwarts the whole purpose of a secret ballot.

The Alton Democrat said he has introduced a bill that would amend the law to strike a passage dealing with undercounting of votes.

MD: Will state pull the plug on new voting machines?
http://www.gazette.net/stories/12252009/polinew160336_32547.php
System’s burden on counties, merger of suppliers stoke worry

State Board of Elections members expressed concerns last week over how a merger between the two largest voting machine manufacturers, which is the subject of an ongoing antitrust probe, could have skewed the procurement process.

MD: CITIZEN JOURNALISM: Maryland eyes paper voting
http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/dec/29/citizen-journalism-maryland-eyes-paper-voting/
Dec 29, 2009. Election boards may abandon $65 million electronic system
…Despite resources made available by HAVA, Maryland is tentatively planning to return to paper ballots for the 2010 election. Maryland would abandon its $65 million electronic system while continuing to pay off capital lease costs associated with electronic voting machines until 2014, according to a story this month in the Frederick News-Post.

In the past decade, the annual budget for the Maryland State Board of Elections has accelerated exponentially. In fiscal 2000, its budget, limited to state funds, was $3.136 million, while in fiscal 2008, with a combination of federal funds from HAVA, state funds and special funds largely coming from county contributions, the Board of Elections’ budget was $27.504 million.

ME: Lawsuit Victories in Maine Referendum Petition Cases
http://www.ballot-access.org/2009/12/29/lawsuit-victories-in-maine-referendum-petition-cases/
December 29th, 2009 On December 21, a lower state court in Maine ruled that if election officials take longer than the time allowed to check petition signatures, then the petition must be deemed valid.

MN: Innovations: City participates in electronic poll book pilot project
http://www.eminnetonka.com/news.cfm?story_id=InnovationsElectronicPollBook
December 22, 2009 The city of Minnetonka has had a longstanding reputation for instituting innovative ideas in order to provide excellent customer service to residents while also using taxpayer dollars wisely.

MO: Legislation filed for early voting in Missouri
http://www.connectmidmissouri.com/news/story.aspx?id=394871
Under Frame’s bill, voters could vote as early as three weeks prior to an election. This measure is similar to House Bill 49, which Frame filed for the 2009 legislative session.

The Voting News Daily: ES&S faces federal hearings, No right to secret ballot in IL? CT Machine recounts machine

Is a Secret Ballot a Right? The answer is NO according to Illinois Attorney General Lisa Madigan: “While plaintiff attempts to suggest to the court that there is a fundamental right to a secret ballot, no such right exists.”
…ES&S/Diebold/Premier faces federal hearings and 14 states have launched investigation into the merger or monopoly…
…CT IRONY #4: Machine Errors Result In Recounting By Machine…

Would a commercial internet voting company know more about security than the pentagon? A Wood County WV commissioner on internet voting pilot for military: “I guess if a hacker can break into the Pentagon’s computer system, they can possibly break into our voting system,” Rick Modesitt, Commission President…

All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CA: A chaotic year for California ballot propositions
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-initiatives27-2009dec27,0,1838547.story
Signatures are being gathered for more than 50 initiatives — big and small, promising and far-fetched

CO: Election Transparency Litigation: Marks v. Koch
http://aspenelectionreview.blogspot.com/2009/12/election-transparency-litigation-marks.html
The suit has the remaining purpose to obtain access to inspect these public records of which all were displayed to the public on May 5 2009, and hundreds are still available for viewing as part of a GrassRootsTV program from election night. If the City’s motion to dismiss is not accepted by the court, there is a court date set for January 22, 2010 when a hearing may be taking place.

CO: One dozen excuses
http://bit.ly/68DlWL
Dear Editor: Mayor Ireland just sent an intriguing e-mail to the “voting rights community” titled “Why we don’t need your help in running our elections and why a recount is not needed.” It probably wasn’t written to amuse, given the personal attacks in it, but recipients surely chuckled.

CO: Add yours to this list of questions about Aspen’s May 5 IRV election
http://aspenelectionreview.blogspot.com/2009/12/ongoing-list-of-questions-to-aspen-and.html
[We are collecting questions and answers about Aspen’s election and also public verifiability of elections in general on this site. Please contribute your own questions (anonymous questions ok).

CT: CT IRONY #4: Machine Errors Result In Recounting By Machine
http://www.ctvoterscount.org/?p=2732
Possibly some machine problems might be mitigated by such a recanvass, yet if there were an error in memory card programming or an error in the software it is quite likely the same discrepancy would be repeated.

HI: Interim elections chief to be selected Wednesday
http://bit.ly/934yQe

IL: Barrow to challenge Detroit mayoral recount
http://www.freep.com/article/20091224/NEWS01/912240394/1001/News/Barrow-to-challenge-Detroit-mayoral-recount
Dec 24, 2009…Barrow attributes his loss to Bing to vote fraud or gross human error.

During the recount, Barrow challenged the November election results on several fronts: mismatched seals on more than 40,000 absentee ballot containers; mismatched seals from poll books of voters’ signatures, and unaccounted for unused ballots that Barrow claims could have been counted for Bing.

IL: Is a Secret Ballot a Right?
http://illinipundit.com/2009/12/16/secret-ballot-right
December 16th, 2009 According to the State Board of Elections, and their attorney, the Illinois Attorney General, the answer is NO.

IL: Voting law proceeding despite concerns
http://www.pekintimes.com/news/x1689182012/Voting-law-proceeding-despite-concerns
PEKIN, Ill. – Voting this February could be a little more complicated.
Thanks to a provision passed by the Illinois State Legislature and signed into law by then-Governor Rod Blagojevich in 2007, if a voter fails to vote for any particular office, many voting machines throughout the state will beep loudly and spit the ballot back out.

The Voting News Daily: Diebold $100M e-voting contract in Brazil, An unhealthy monopoly, Internet voting quagmire

Correction: Headline on Dec 23 should have said investigation into DETROIT’s election, not Chicago. We corrected that headline here.

Diebold’s sale to ES&S an “Unhealthy Monopoly”and meanwhile Diebold still selling voting machines – in Brazil?

Internet voting: Wood Co. WV has volunteered to test voting project that “would allow overseas, military absentee voting online”. Meanwhile the “FCC Wanders into the Internet Voting Quagmire” writes The Open Source Digital Voting Foundation…Is the internet secure for voting? Recent media reports that “Hackers’ attacks rise in volume, sophistication..U.S. defense officials revealed in April that hackers have stolen thousands of files on one of the military’s most advanced fighter aircrafts.”…

All that, some videos, podcasts and more in today’s voting news below…

CA: Republican Party Sues to Overturn San Diego Law Making it Illegal for Parties to Contribute to Candidates for City Office
http://www.ballot-access.org/2009/12/24/republican-party-sues-to-overturn-san-diego-law-making-it-illegal-for-parties-to-contribute-to-candidates-for-city-office/

CA: Learn all about Voting by Mail! YouTube Video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wzkmgZPBRY4
Created by the Santa Clara County Registrar of Voters. From signing up, to completing and returning your ballot, to how your ballot gets verified and counted – this overview will explain how Voting by Mail is Easy, Convenient, Safe, and Secure.
For Tagalog, Vietnamese or Spanish, visit this link
http://www.youtube.com/user/sccvote

CO: Public Radio – KAJX – reports on Aspen election satire (podcast and blog)
http://aspenelectionreview.blogspot.com/2009/12/kajx-covers-better-bad-news-lampoon-of.html

CO: Election questions (lte by Harvie Branscomb electon integrity activist)
http://bit.ly/6QSiwg What might a citizen risk by asking questions? From my perspective, two voluntary commissioners were recently dismissed following an unjust smear campaign that prevented their pursuit of election quality improvements. It appears to me that their principal error was to ask difficult questions.

CO: Aspen City Attorney Jim True and Mayor Mick Ireland separately respond to my letter (Harvie Branscomb)
http://aspenelectionreview.blogspot.com/2009/12/aspen-city-attorney-jim-true-and-mayor.html

FL: An unhealthy monopoly
http://www.miamiherald.com/opinion/editorials/story/1396762.html
12.24.2009. OUR OPINION: McCollum right to conduct anti-trust inquiry into voting-machine owners’ merger.
The only people who benefit from monopolies are their owners. For the rest of us, monopolies mean being powerless because we have no choices.

GA: Three Complaints Filed Against Georgia Sec. of State Inspector General
http://electiondefensealliance.org/GA-Inspector-General-complaints
The complaints filed against the Inspector General’s office allege that investigations involving electronic voting machine defects and controversies were improperly handled.

NH: EDA Exit Polls Generally Match 2008 Election Results, But Find “Wide Disparities” in NH Vote Counts
http://electiondefensealliance.org/EDA-Exit-Polls-2008

TN: The Logic of Voting WREK radio show (podcast)
http://smartech.gatech.edu/handle/1853/31396
Wednesday Dec. 23th noon-1pm Voting activist Bernie Ellis, who joined us previously to talk about how high tech voting machines aren’t always the best solution, returns to our show. He will provide us with an update on what is going on in Tennessee regarding this important issue.

TX: Boerne may face challenge of single-member voting districts
http://boernestar.com/articles/2009/12/26/news/doc4b364cd062fa5729254884.txt
December 26, 2009 Residents challenging the Boerne City Council’s recent decision to create single-member council districts say it violates the city charter and the Texas Constitution.

TX: Texas Democratic Party Finally Gets Relief Against Vote-Counting Machines
http://www.ballot-access.org/2009/12/22/texas-democratic-party-finally-gets-relief-against-vote-counting-machines/
December 22nd, 2009 The ruling does not say these machines violate the Constitution. Rather, it says that when Dallas County started using that type of machine in 1998, that was a voting procedure change and it should have been submitted to the U.S.

The Voting News Daily: Detroit candidate calls for election investigation, Fixing our broken democracy, ACORN cleared again

Former Mayoral Candidate Tom Barrow called for official review of the Nov 3 mayoral election “when he discovered empty ballot boxes and numerous ballot boxes with security seals which been breached, disqualifying tens of thousands of votes …from being recountable… ‘computer tapes’, normally summarizing election results at the closing of the polls, had in fact actually been run hours before the closing of the polls indicating that the results were being electronically manipulated…”

The President appointed a Cyber Czar. Luther Weeks, CTVotersCount comments: “Our concern is with the disconnect that has otherwise intelligent people concerned with cyber security based on strong evidence, coupled with the almost simultaneous support for voting by Internet, email, and fax.”..
.Brad Friedman reports that “ACORN Cleared YET AGAIN of Wrongdoing”…
In Fixing Our Broken Democracy, Professor Stephen Unger writes: “The warning, ‘Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty’, applies regardless of the election mechanics used.”...

All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CA: California: somehow pols are evading the campaign finance laws. Who’d a thunk it?
http://www.votelaw.com/blog/archives/006343.html

FL: Chambless urges delay in voting machine switch
http://www.claytoday.biz/content/1848_1.php
Dec 23. GREEN COVE SPRINGS — Supervisor of Elections Chris H. Chambless has gotten local legislative support for proposing a deadline on changing voting equipment for physically challenged voters

The Florida State Association of Supervisors of Elections (FSASE) is asking that changing to the AutoMark system be delayed until 2016, thus allowing counties to continue using their current Americans with Disabilitities (ADA) voting system

FL: License renewal to require a lot more identification
http://www.gainesville.com/article/20091223/ARTICLES/912231002/1002
Getting a driver’s license will require a whole lot more ID

The Department of Homeland Security reports that Real ID will improve security at federal buildings, nuclear facilities and aircraft, prevent people from fraudulently obtaining public benefits such as Medicare and Medicaid, prevent the hiring of illegal immigrants, prevent illegal firearm purchases and slow voter fraud.

IL: Military and Overseas Ballots in the Mail
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2009/12/22/military-and-overseas-ballots-in-the-mail
Champaign County Clerk I’ve written about the problems of ballot certification as it relates to getting ballots to military and overseas voters. Well today we mailed the last of the initial mailing of 484 ballots

MI: Election Investigation * (missing ballots, 50,000 absentee ballots disqualified)
http://www.tv20detroit.com/news/79988432.html
12/22/2009…Former Mayoral Candidate Tom Barrow is calling for an official review of the November third mayoral election. Mr. Barrow met with city officials at the Flynn Pavilion on Belle Isle to discuss allegations of voter fraud.

The concerns stem from missing ballots and signatures from several districts during the night of the election.

MI: Barrow Investigates City Elections *(suspicion results electronically manipulated)
http://bit.ly/8xWOoQ 21 Dec 2009. DETROIT, Mich. – Former mayoral candidate Tom Barrow has turned a routine recount of election precincts into a sweeping indictment of the entire conduct of elections in Detroit when he discovered empty ballot boxes
and numerous ballot boxes with security seals which been breached, disqualifying tens of thousands of votes in the November 3, 2009 general election from being recountable.

Barrow’s team of lawyers, accountants and volunteers also challenged dozens of precinct’s whose election results “computer tapes”, normally summarizing election results at the closing of the polls, had in fact actually been run hours before the closing of the polls indicating that the results were being electronically manipulated and the numbers being shown not the final results.

The Voting News Daily: Dallas Co. violated law in voting machine use, Diebold Sale may see recount

WA SOS to introduce bill in 2010 to “allow overseas and military residents to return their ballots by fax or e-mail.” …A three-judge panel has ruled that Dallas County election officials violated federal law when they did not inform the Department of Justice about changes in the way straight-party votes are counted on electronic voting machines….The trial of former NM SOS Rebecca Vigil-Giron…”has been set for July”…Update: see Pennsylvania Court voting machine ruling r/e Banfield Order 121509…Open source voting system development is alive and well….

All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CA: Voters sue over Novato Sanitary election *
http://www.contracostatimes.com/news/ci_14044648?nclick_check=1
12/21/2009 A pair of voters, claiming they were disenfranchised because they weren’t given the chance to vote, filed a lawsuit late Monday to contest the results of the Nov. 3 election for three seats on the Novato Sanitary District board.

FL: Sumter Elections office wants delay of Florida law
http://www.dailycommercial.com/localnews/story/121709machines
BUSHNELL — You can say the cost adds up to about $60,000 per disabled voter in Sumter County.

Although the office said the county only has six voters that its deems as needing the disabled accessible machine, a law requires Florida counties to have the equipment for each of its precincts by 2012.


GA: Handel resigns as Ga. secretary of state
http://atlanta.bizjournals.com/atlanta/stories/2009/12/21/daily17.html
Karen Handel announced Tuesday she is resigning as Georgia’s secretary of state to concentrate on the 2010 governor’s race

HI: In Hawaii, Cuts Reach to Core Functions
http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/20/us/20hawaii.html?_r=1
The State Elections Office said it might not be able to afford a pending special election, which could leave half of the state’s population without a voice in the House of Representatives until September.

HI: CommonCauseHI
http://twitter.com/CommonCauseHI/status/6906370244
Elections Comm meets Dec 30 at 10am to discuss special election and new elections chief

KS: An update on election news from Kansas Secretary of State Ron Thornburgh
Double voting leads to conviction in Nemaha County.
http://www.kssos.org/forms/communication/canvassing_kansas/dec09.pdf

IL: eVoter Specimen Ballot Mistake
Champaign County Clerk
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2009/12/22/evoter-specimen-ballot-mistake/

IL:Ballots tossed in State’s Attorney election*(absentee ballots & residency issues)
http://www.register-news.com/local/local_story_354195232.html
MT. VERNON — A circuit court judge has invalidated a number of ballots in the November 2008 election between Jefferson County State’s Attorney Jeff Bradley and Nicole Villani.

IL: Voter Resources — Absentee Voting in the Illinois Primaries Begins on Thursday, December 24th
http://centralillinois912project.com/?p=2341
The actual primary election here in Illinois will take place on February 2nd. There are a variety of resources (especially online resources) that you can use to ensure that your vote is an informed one!

NM: Trial of Vigil-Giron, others set for July
http://fwix.com/albuquerque/share/e7ba658fa7/trial_of_vigil-giron_others_set_for_july
Vigil-Giron, lobbyists Joseph Kupfer and Elizabeth Kupfer and media consultant Armando Gutierrez, who headed the company Vigil-Giron hired to help the state implement a federal voter education program, each face 50 counts including money laundering, fraud, soliciting or receiving kickbacks and tax evasion. They allegedly took the money between 2004 and 2006 using the secretary of state’s contract with Gutierrez by falsifying invoices.

NY: Senate working to avoid voting problems in 2010
http://www.legislativegazette.com/Articles-c-2009-12-21-64421.113122_Senate_working_to_avoid_voting_problems_in_2010.html
December 21, 2009 The Senate Elections Committee heard testimony last month from county officials on how to best implement optical scan voting statewide for the 2010 elections.

The Voting News Daily: PA e-voting court victory, DoJ Now Investigating Diebold/ES&S Merger

Pennsylvania Case Challenging the Use of Electronic Voting Machines Now Moves Toward Trial: “We now look forward to moving this case toward trial,” says Mary Kohart, a partner at Drinker Biddle & Reath LLP, one of the lawyers representing the voters. “There is overwhelming evidence showing that electronic voting machines are unreliable and insecure for the counting and recording of votes…”

Comments to the FCC on Internet Voting by Candice Hoke: “The Internet voting pilot programs were structured by for-profit vendors, who also reported on their “success” without any independent evaluation and transparency on some critical dimensions.


All this and much more in today’s voting news below….

CO: *Marks provides important service*
http://bit.ly/8MNp80
Dear Editor: Litigation has been filed in Aspen regarding the issue of the public
right to examine anonymous digital ballot images. This issue, of
national importance, offers an important improvement to voting rights
introduced by computerized voting machines, which conceal counting of
the vote.

GA: Roswell: Close vote shows need for a ballot paper trail
http://www.ajc.com/opinion/roswell-close-vote-shows-246777.html
December 18, 2009 …The problem is that whatever is contained on those plastic cards is what is recounted, whether it is accurate information reflecting the voter’s choices — or not. But apparently recount is the wrong term to use with respect to these cards, as they can only be “recanvassed,” which means that the totals will be exactly the same as the previously unverifiable results.

IL: Use eVoter at your peril
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2009/12/21/use-evoter-at-your-peril/
Champaign County Clerk A company has begun trying to make money off of our voter registration data. When I first heard about their effort, I had concerns.

Unfortunately, their site only adds an unnecessary and burdensome step for Champaign County voters.

MI: Michigan Residency Requirement for Recall Petitioners Struck Down
http://www.ballot-access.org/2009/12/20/michigan-residency-requirement-for-recall-petitioners-struck-down/

MN: SOS Mark Ritchie Proposed Permanent Rules Relating to Elections
http://www.sos.state.mn.us/index.aspx?page=753
Including Amendments to Rules Governing Petitions, Absentee Ballots, Certification and Testing of Voting Systems, Recounts, Election Judge Training Program, Ballot Preparation and Redistricting, Minnesota Rules, chapters 8205, 8210, 8220, 8230, 8235, 8240, 8250 and 8255.

MT: Gazette opinion: Consolidating voting at Metra makes sense
http://billingsgazette.com/news/opinion/editorial/gazette-opinion/article_4d61f042-ed23-11de-8039-001cc4c03286.html
December 20, 2009 …Many people had misgivings about consolidating 28 polling places into one. Critics predicted long lines and chaos. They were wrong.

NC: State orders new election in Fair Bluff mayor’s race *
http://www.fayobserver.com/Articles/2009/12/18/961620
Mayor Spruell R. Britt lost the election by just two votes – 191 to 189 – to challenger Chris Scott. Testimony and affidavits presented to the county board showed that five people voted who later acknowledged that they did not live within the town limits.

PA: PA: Pennsylvania Court Ruling Banfield Order 121509
http://voteraction.org/files/Banfield%20Order%20121509.pdf
Protective order for ES&S and Sequoia – denied. Petitioners (Banfield and clients) have 20 days to arrive at a mutually satisfactory protective order.
background.
PENNSYLVANIA STATE SUPREME COURT ALLOWS VOTING RIGHTS CASE TO PROCEED

http://www.voteraction.org/node/776
Dec 18 2008 State’s Highest Court Denies Pennsylvania Secretary of State Permission to Appeal Lower Court Ruling in Voters’ Favor Case Challenging the Use of Electronic Voting Machines Now Moves Toward Trial

WI: Clerks critical of Wisconsin’s early voting law
http://www.fox21online.com/news/clerks-critical-wisconsins-early-voting-law

Verified Voting Blog: Candice Hoke Comments to the FCC on Internet Voting

In her response to an FCC’s question about what can we learn from pilot projects that have tested online voting, Verified Voting Foundation Board of Advisors member Candice Hoke observed that none of the domestic internet voting pilot projects have been properly structured to test for and approximate the risks that would be posed to domestic US elections. Specifically, she noted that these pilots are especially remiss in conceptualizing the risks for elections to Federal and Statewide office, where the fiscal control over billions of dollars is concerned, and the direction of military powers and foreign policy/aid.

Hoke continued: "The Internet voting pilot programs were structured by for-profit vendors, who also reported on their “success” without any independent evaluation and transparency on some critical dimensions. In Hawai’i, the project did report a dramatic drop in the reported rate of voter participation. The pilot, however, did not include any structures by which an assessment could be conducted of whether technical attacks had occurred to intercept, modify or otherwise block voted ballots from reaching the election processing location. Nor did it offer any auditing assessments that the ballots as tabulated matched the ballots as cast by voters. Thus, no conclusions can be drawn about the pilot’s success, and it bears little relation to a Federal or Statewide election context.

The Voting News Daily: Military Bases to aid voter registration, One company to count 70% of US votes

Big news: The Department of Defense has agreed to formally designate all military installation voting assistance offices as official “voter registration agencies”. The move “will provide these brave Americans and their families with ‘motor voter’-style registration assistance on military installations, where they spend most of their time,” Cornyn said. Schumer called the change “a bold step by the Pentagon that will turn U.S. military bases across the globe into one-stop shops for active-duty troops who wish to vote.”

Regarding voting machine merger: “ES&S, of course, told the Herald/Times that their acquisition of Diebold ‘will result in better products and services for all customers and voters alike.’ And, if you believe that, we’ve got an unhackable voting machine to sell you” ~ Brad Friedman at Bradblog….FL: Attorney General Bill McCollum responds to voter advocate’s letter…Verified Voting has several updates of interest…


All this and more in today’s voting news below…..

FL: Florida AG Probing ES&S/Diebold Merger for Anti-trust Violations
http://www.bradblog.com/?p=7584
Demon coupling will result in company counting 92% of Sunshine State votes, at least 70% nation wide…

FL: Attorney General Bill McCollum responds to voter advocate’s letter
http://blogs.tampabay.com/buzz/2009/12/mccollum-responds-to-voter-advocates-letter.html
As part of his investigation of a voting-machine company merger that would create a near-monopoly over voting machines, Attorney General Bill McCollum has sent the following letter to Dan McCrea of the Florida Voters Foundation…

HI: US funds for Hawaii special election possible
http://www.kpua.net/news.php?id=19233
HONOLULU (AP) — Hawaii’s chief election officer is suggesting the state ask federal officials if the state can use federal funds to conduct a special election to fill the remainder of the term of Rep. Neil Abercrombie.

IL: Recount nearly over, Barrow still claims fraud in mayor’s race *
http://www.detnews.com/article/20091218/METRO/912180452/1361/Recount-nearly-over–Barrow-still-claims-fraud-in-mayor-s-race
Detroit– Former mayoral candidate Tom Barrow is continuing to allege voter fraud in the Nov. 3 election, claiming he’s found empty ballot boxes and several others whose security seals were breached.

Barrow, who filed a recount after losing to Mayor Dave Bing 58-42 percent, said the breech should disqualify tens of thousands of votes from being recounted

IL: Election commission registering some voters at home
http://www.mysuburbanlife.com/carolstream/newsnow/x1431156019/Election-commission-registering-some-voters-at-home
Downers Grove, IL — The DuPage County Election Commission is offering in-home voter registration for elderly and disabled residents leading up to next year’s state and national primaries

IL: Suit against optical scanning machine rejected
http://www.news-gazette.com/news/local/2009/12/18/suit_against_optical_scanning_machine_rejected
December 18, 2009 URBANA – Despite efforts by Champaign County Clerk Mark Shelden to prevent it, voters in the primary election in February may hear their voting machines beeping…

Shelden argued, according to court documents submitted in support of his request, that “the right of Champaign County voters to a secret ballot has been compromised” by a change in the state election laws, which require all optical scan ballot tabulation machines to produce an error message when a voter “undervotes” or fails to vote for one or more statewide constitutional office races.

NJ: Tally wavers on legal representation in Atlantic City voter fraud case *
http://www.pressofatlanticcity.com/news/breaking/article_9b33458e-ec2c-11de-a1c3-001cc4c03286.html
Tally is among 14 people – including Atlantic City Councilman Marty Small – charged with improperly handling messenger ballots in Small’s failed mayoral bid.

The Voting News Daily: Voting-machine merger sparks FL anti-trust probe, Funding Hawaii election

Florida Atty Gen investigates voting-machine company merger: “Florida counties are negotiating their contracts now to prepare for the 2010 elections,” McCrea said. “They can suffer the potential damages for dealing with a monopoly now. So intervention needs to happen now.”~ Dan McCrea, president of the Florida Voters Foundation…Hawaii may be able to use HAVA funds to pay for special elections….Maryland Governor being pressured to delay switch to paper ballot voting systems…Comment to a Tennessee newspaper: “You get a receipt when you buy a burger and fries; isn’t your vote more valuable than that? Or are the people of Tennessee really content to drop their vote into a black hole and assume that there’s absolute certainty that it will be counted?”. The voting news might look slightly different today as we adjust the format slightly.

All this and more in today’s voting news….

FL: Voting-machine firms’ merger sparks Florida anti-trust probe
http://www.mcclatchydc.com/251/story/80830.html
…Under Florida’s 1980 anti-trust law, McCollum could persuade a court to levy fines against ES&S or prevent the company from operating in the state…

FL: Voting-machine merger investigated
http://www.miamiherald.com/news/florida/story/1385770.html
Dec 17, 2009 – Florida Attorney General Bill McCollum is conducting an anti-trust investigation of a voting-machine company merger that would create a near-monopoly over the levers of democracy in Florida and much of the United States

HI: Federal money may fund election
http://twi.cc/CPAq

HI: Salvage the special election
http://www.starbulletin.com/editorials/20091216_Salvage_the_special_election.html
Dec 16, 2009 …Cronin said one way to deal with the problem is to conduct an election by ballots to be mailed in or dropped off at central locations to reduce costs. That system was used successfully in April to conduct a special election in Windward Oahu to replace the late Barbara Marshall on the City Council.

IL: Injunction Denied
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2009/12/17/injunction-denied/
Champaign County Clerk- Judge Jones today agreed to a lot of our arguments, but in the end, disagreed with the argument that our office would suffer irreparable harm should we go forward with the election with the undervote provision in place.

MA: The debate voters deserve: Coakley vs. Brown
http://twi.cc/tAxK

MD: O’Malley: Questions Raised About Voting Scanners
http://wjz.com/local/voting.scanners.paper.2.1374714.html
ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) Gov. Martin O’Malley says more and more people are asking about the wisdom of changing to a new voting system with optical scans of paper ballots for upcoming elections….

MT: Voters voice concern over plan to shutter Missoula polling places
http://www.missoulian.com/news/local/article_38a0ff68-eacb-11de-a145-001cc4c002e0.html
Dec 17, 2009 – Dozens of voters turned out Wednesday afternoon, most of them opposing the proposed closure of several polling places – including at the Missoula County Courthouse and on the University of Montana campus – saying the plan would hurt the democratic process…

ND: Ramsey County votes to go to one polling place, fewer precincts
http://www.devilslakejournal.com/news/x967377813/Ramsey-County-votes-to-go-to-one-polling-place-fewer-precincts
Dec 16, 2009. “We expect more and more people will be participating in the Vote by Mail Program,” said County Auditor Elizabeth Fischer at the regular Ramsey County Commission meeting held Tuesday evening.

NY: Election Officials Hold Voting Machine Test Run (video available)
http://ny1.com/7-brooklyn-news-content/top_stories/110601/election-officials-hold-voting-machine-test-run

TN: What They Said
http://www.memphisflyer.com/memphis/what-they-said/Content?oid=1867114
Comments from memphisflyer.com

The Voting News Daily: Madison Co KY gets paper ballots, Hawaii ponders mail-in special election, IL no secret ballot? Voting News wants to hear from you

Too broke to hold elections? Hawaii considers vote by mail for upcoming special election. New Mexico’s Secretary of State says will have to borrow money to hold upcoming primary…More concern in Illinois about special state law that requires undervote notification- the machines make an audible noise if a voter leaves certain contests blank….Madison KY switches back to paper ballot voting systems…NY approves voting machines, requires vendors to bring them into full compliance….Security Heavyweights predict 2010 threats…..

We would like to hear from you. Do you have questions, concerns, or complaints about the voting news? Do you like the voting news like it is? Did we miss an important article? How can voting news help you more? If you would like to tell us how you feel, please email us at ncvoter (at) gmail.com. Also, if you like voting news, please tell a friend or donate .

Well, here’s today’s voting news…..

CA: Supervisors end contract with voting vendor
12/15/2009 As Los Angeles County seeks to replace a voting system that has been subject to sharp criticism from state officials, the Board of Supervisors voted Tuesday to terminate a contract with one of the system’s main vendors.

Logan’s office has been seeking input on what kind of new voting system the public would like in the county. For more information, log onto http://www.lavote.net/Voter/VSAP
http://www.contracostatimes.com/california/ci_14003230

FL: Federal Voting Assistance Program News
Florida Voters, Submit Your Ballot Request NOW for the February 2, 2009 Special Primary!
http://www.fvap.gov/global/news/nr21-2009.html

HI: Hawaii Ponders All-Mail Ballot Election in Next Special Congressional Election
http://www.ballot-access.org/2009/12/16/hawaii-ponders-all-mail-ballot-election-in-next-special-congressional-election/

IL: Illinois State Board of Elections “No Right To Secret Ballot”
Champaign County Clerk, IL
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2009/12/16/illinois-state-board-of-elections-%e2%80%9cno-right-to-secret-ballot%e2%80%9d/

KY: County preparing for paper ballot voting
Madison County…This year, a paper ballot voting system will be used, which is the same process that was used before electronic voting machines became mainstream.

“We’ve gone back to voting the way we did 25 years ago,” said Madison Judge/Executive Kent Clark.
http://www.richmondregister.com/localnews/local_story_350075220.html

NM: Secretary of state: Election funding is lacking
12/16/2009 FARMINGTON — Secretary of State Mary Herrera complained Tuesday of a lack of funding for the primary election, but insisted she and her staff were trying to make progress amid budget cuts from the legislature.

She also complained that the department has $814,000 to hold the primary election in June, but needs almost $4 million total. She said the state must borrow the rest of the money to hold the primary.
http://www.daily-times.com/ci_14006966

NY: FYI – Bo Lipari writes: “Here’s a paper I did on it some years ago which describes the two specific sections of HAVA which preclude retaining lever machines.”
http://www.nyvv.org/newdoc/2009/LeverMachinesAndHAVA020909.pdf

NYS Certifies Non-Compliant Voting Machines
Commentary Written by Howard Stanislevic
15 December 2009 Editor’s Note: The NYS Board Of Elections certified both the Dominion ImageCast and the ES&S Electronic voting systems at 1:10 p.m. today (Dec. 15th, 2009) .. noting in the process that the machines were still “non-compliant.” The state passed an additional resolution requiring the operations department to work with the two vendors to bring the machines into full compliance.

The Voting News Daily: NY certifies voting machines, OH touchscreen flaws, Aspen election lampooned, I-voting squibs

Lampooned: Aspen’s chronic election problems via YouTube video. The portrayal of the ballot box just outside the mayor’s office during “early early” voting was outrageous yet true…
Calibration issues with Montgomery County Ohio Diebold touchscreens but the vendor will “fix” them for free…No machines, no money, no state election director: .Hawaii can’t afford a special election…NH’s electronic voting panel issuing report after meeting with Finnish e-voting expert Harri Hursti today… NY Board of Elections certified new voting machines,flaws and all in time to avoid federal intervention..Want Fair and Accurate Elections in Tennessee? Call Your Senator Today…Internet voting continues to metastasize in Canada…

AL: Cedar Bluff election results (finally) in
CEDAR BLUFF — It took over 16 months to seat them, but the Cedar Bluff Town Council finally has three new members…
http://www.postpaper.com/cbelection09.htm

CO: ASPEN ELECTION NOT OUT OF CONTROL (Satire – on YouTube)
Produced by betterbadnews December 14, 2009
…In Colorado early voting is taken very seriously. A ballot box set up near the mayors office gives voters something to do while waiting for their appointment with the boss.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R1F5Jlzs6a8&videos=IyVyyTQY27Q

CO: Who decides what the people may know?
Aspen….What is the city hiding, and why?

Aspen has chronic, unseen but undeniable election integrity problems.

Election integrity, the fundamental building block of our society, is waved off as unimportant detail in Aspen….
http://www.aspentimes.com/article/20091215/LETTER/912149987/1020&ParentProfile=1058

CT: Miles Rapoport: Demos Leader and former CT Secretary of the State
December 15, 2009 http://www.ctvoterscount.org/?p=2689

HI: Election chief says special vote would be difficult
Dec 11, 2009 The state Office of Elections has not made a decision on how, or even if, a special election would be held once U.S. Rep. Neil Abercrombie decides to vacate his seat in Congress.

Abercrombie says he will announce Sunday his intent to step down to concentrate on his run at the governorship in 2010.

“That is a possibility,” Cronin said at a press conference today. “It would be a matter of discussing among all the election officials the question of the capacity of the Office of Election to administer an election when we’re already experiencing significantly reduced staffing, virtually no funding to get us to June 30, 2010, and no voting machines.”
http://www.starbulletin.com/news/bulletin/79107482.html

IL: Board nixes funding for voting machine upgrades
December 13, 2009 JERSEYVILLE — The Jersey County Board hopes to send a message to state legislators by refusing to fund changes in voting equipment that will be required by a new “under-voting” law.

Jersey County Clerk Steve Pohlman asked the board for $4,000 from the general fund to pay for reprogramming of election computers so that the equipment can immediately report when a voter fails to fill in a space on the ballot.
http://www.thetelegraph.com/news/upgrades-34133-board-voting.html

IL: Policitican accused of buying votes with $2 bills says ‘that’s just crazy’
EAST ST. LOUIS — Politician Will McGaughy says he’s been mailing envelopes to voters in his precinct at Christmastime for 30 years, wishing them holiday cheer and including a crisp $2 bill as a “keepsake.”

But what makes this year different said Dancy is what McGaughy conceded is his first combined Christmas and candidacy message.

The Voting News Daily: National Expert warns FCC of internet voting dangers, Vendor put on EAC advisory panel, Tennessee stall n crawl

In answer to the question “With existing technology, is it possible to enable and ensure safe and secure voting online today?”, Verified Voting responded, “in a word, no.” It is likely that no one in the country has studied the subject of internet voting more intensely than David Jefferson, senior scientist at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. Jefferson warns: “Even if an Internet election is apparently ‘successful’, the results are absolutely unauditable in any meaningful sense of the word….You may hear claims that many elections and election pilots have been conducted in the past without the loss or misrecording of a single vote. This claim is false on several levels.” Internet voting seems even more insane as the Guardian UK reports that “Russia and US in secret talks to fight net crime”…

Hawaii Oh No: Hawaii’s election dept faces new budget woes – the state will have to come up with $2 million to run a special election to replace U.S. Rep. Neil Abercrombie, who is leaving congress to run for governor. Add this to the fact that Hawaii’s election dept is woefully under funded, is in the process of creating new election rules, is considering cutting half of its polling places and does not have a voting system in place…Randolph County Indiana’s 2 year struggle to get SOS to reimburse costs of voting machines that should be paid by HAVA funds…

The End of Innocence — NY State Board of Elections Says Ballot Scanners Switched Votes in 2009 General Election…Local Groups Urge VA Gov Kaine to Restore Voting Rights… Tennessee continues ‘stall ‘n’ crawl’ tactics…

BradBlog reports: “Disgraceful: Discredited E-Voting Vendor VP Appointed to U.S. EAC Advisory Panel”

All this and more in today’s voting news below….

CT: Secretary of the State Candidate Criticizes Exploratory Committees
December 12. “In our view exploratory committees represent a loophole in the current public financing law. Candidates can collect and spend huge sums in the name of exploring runs for office.”
http://www.ctvoterscount.org/?p=2671

FL: The Advancement Project warns of problems with upcoming elections
A report released Thursday by the Advancement Project calls for changes in poll hours and voter registrations rules.
TALLAHASSEE — Even though Election Day last year went relatively smoothly across Florida, a civil rights advocacy group that focuses on elections warned that stricter voter registration laws could prevent thousands of eligible voters from joining the rolls in upcoming elections.
http://www.miamiherald.com/news/politics/story/1376506.html

HI: Abercrombie will quit Congress to focus on Hawaii governor race
Quitting Congress to prepare for likely battle with mayor
…Abercrombie’s decision throws a curve into the 2010 elections and triggers a special election to fill the remaining months of his two-year term.

The unexpected vacancy could lead the state Office of Elections to try to come up with as much as $2 million to pay for a special election and scramble to find a voting system because legal challenges have left the state with no voting machines.
http://twi.cc/HDjv

IN: County Council OKs voting reimbursement
Randolph County Council Tuesday approved County Clerk Claudia Thornburg’s submission of an application for the county to be reimbursed $194,048 for the purchase of its current voting machines.

Verified Voting Blog: Comments to the FCC on Internet Voting

It is likely that no one in the country has studied the subject of internet voting more intensely than David Jefferson, senior scientist at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory. Part of his job is to help devise strategies to defend against the relentless attacks we see every hour of every day against U.S. networks, both government and corporate, from sources ranging from self aggrandizing students to foreign intelligence and cyber warfare agencies. He has also been deeply involved in voting and election security for over a decade as a voting technology advisor to five successive Secretaries of State in California, and is a coauthor of most of the best known peer-reviewed scientific publication on Internet voting, the SERVE Security Report.

[pullquote align="left"]“The integrity of a general election is as important as the integrity of many of our national defense secrets.[/pullquote]In his comments to the FCC, Jefferson emphasizes that election security is an aspect of U.S. national security. He observes that, “few people have any idea how tiny is the fraction of votes that, if selectively lost or switched, could swing a presidential election, or swing the balance of power in a house of Congress. The controversial 2000 presidential election that was decided by a few hundred votes in one state was only the most extreme object lesson, but other elections such as the recent Minnesota senatorial election, have been as close. This is all the more true in these times in which the electorate is nearly evenly divided on several key national issues. It is vital that we protect the security of every vote, or the legitimacy of our government will be rightly called into question--a situation that is very damaging in a democracy.”

Verified Voting Blog: Verified Voting Comments to FCC on Internet Voting

In the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Recovery Act), Congress directed the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), as part of its development of a National Broadband Plan, to include “a plan for the use of broadband infrastructure and services in advancing …civic participation.” On December 10, 2010 the Federal Communications Commission issued a request for public comments “…on how broadband can help to bring democratic processes—including elections, public hearings and town hall meetings—into the digital age…” Verified Voting, in submitted comments, answered the question – “With existing technology, is it possible to enable and ensure safe and secure voting online today?”, simply – “In a word, no.” As a recent report from the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) indicates, “…The security challenges associated with e-mail return of voted ballots are difficult to overcome using technology widely deployed today.” And “…Technology that is widely deployed today is not able to mitigate many of the threats to casting ballots via the web.

Despite the short window allowed for public comment, numerous organizations and individuals, including Verified Voting submitted comments. Much of Verified Voting’s commentary was informed by the "Computer Technologists’ Statement on Internet Voting”, published last year and signed by dozens of leading technology professionals and computer security experts. This post is the first in a series that will highlight the commentary submitted to the FCC on the issue of the role of the internet in the electoral process. In answer to the question “With existing technology, is it possible to enable and ensure safe and secure voting online today?”, Verified Voting responded, “in a word, no.”

The Voting News Daily: A NO vote on certifying NY’s voting machines,TX polling place burglary, UT troops internet voting guinea pigs?

Still think internet voting is a great idea? The Senate Select Committee on Intelligence has set up a bi-partisan taskforce on cybersecurity to evaluate potential online threats and provide recommendations for action to the US intelligence community….Although the US is struggling to prevent online threats, there’s a 50 state whack-a-mole agenda to promote internet voting/non secret ballots to our overseas troops. Next to drink the kool-aid: A Utah govt commission recommends Internet voting for military…Yesterday was the deadline to comment to the FCC about internet voting….

No decision on Citizens United for at least a month…Romania court orders recount of 138,000 void votes, Romanian spy chief questioned over election fraud…

The new voting systems do not meet New York’s standards for voting systems, says voting machine expert/activist Bo Lipari. Bo blogs today about being the only “no” vote on a NY citizens committee that makes recommendations on voting systems: “…the findings show that as of today, while the two voting systems have managed to meet most of the New York’s requirements, they have not yet met all of them, including some which to me, as a technologist, are important.” Meanwhile, Brad Friedman writes has a guest column at the Gouverneur Times titled “Officials Were Warned”…

Congratulations to Douglas W. Jones, associate professor of computer science at University of Iowa for his appointment to the EAC’s Technical Guidelines Development Committee…

All this and more in today’s voting news below…

CA: Longtime Vernon mayor, scion of ruling family, convicted of voter fraud *
December 4, 2009 A former mayor of Vernon and his wife were convicted today of voter fraud and conspiracy, capping a three-year legal saga that ended the family’s long grip on the tiny industrial city in southeast Los Angeles County.

Prosecutors accused Leonis and Dominica Malburg of engaging in an elaborate sham in which they pretended to reside in Vernon while they actually lived in a large home in the Hancock Park area of Los Angeles, said Deputy Dist. Atty. Max Huntsman.
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2009/12/longtime-vernon-mayor-scion-of-ruling-family-convicted-of-voter-fraud.html

FL: Pasco County supervisor of elections recruiting volunteer poll workers
Thursday, December 10, 2009. Pasco Supervisor of Elections Brian Corley is looking for volunteers who like to work with people and serve the community as poll workers. These volunteers help with the voting process in precincts across Pasco County on election days.
http://www.tampabay.com/news/localgovernment/pasco-county-supervisor-of-elections-recruiting-volunteer-poll-workers/1057733

IL: State Certification Has Election Officials Up Against a Wall
Champaign County Clerk I’ve written a couple times about the MOVE Act, a recently passed federal law that mandates among other items that election officials mail ballots to military and overseas voters at least 45 days in advance of the election.

We’ve basically have a day to create, proof, and get the ballots out in time to meet the new federal standard. While the new law doesn’t apply to this particular election, it does highlight the practical difficulties that election officials will face in upcoming elections.
http://blog.champaigncountyclerk.com/2009/12/11/state-certification-has-election-officials-up-against-a-wall/

IL: Unfunded mandate protested
Dec. 10, 2009 The Iroquois County Board on Tuesday approved a resolution recommended by board member John Dowling to protest “another unfunded mandate” from the state — this one the required equipping of voting machines with computer chips to let voters know they “under-voted.”

Verified Voting Blog: Polling Place Burglary Raises Specter of Fraud

The burglary at one of Houston's early voting locations (“Computers stolen at early polling location; Ballot board to check electronic voting machines for tampering,” Page B2, Tuesday) raises the specter of election fraud. Some computers were stolen, and as far as we know, the voting machines stored at Hester House were untouched. But if the burglars wanted to tamper with the election outcome, what could they have accomplished? In 2007, California Secretary of State Debra Bowen put together a team to conduct a security analysis of the state's electronic voting systems. I was part of the team analyzing the Hart InterCivic voting system — the same type we use here in Harris County. Our report concluded that the Hart system has a wide variety of security flaws and that it can be attacked in a manner that makes it hard to detect and correct. We further concluded that these attacks can be carried out by a single individual without extensive effort and without long-term access to the equipment. Our results were corroborated by a follow-up study conducted by the Ohio secretary of state.

Did the Houston burglars tamper with the voting machines? I hope not. Could they have tampered with the voting machines? Absolutely. Could we determine if tampering had occurred? Only if we got lucky and found clearly incriminating evidence, such as the burglar's fingerprints near the connectors on the backs of the voting machines.

Verified Voting Blog: My Vote on NY Voting Machine Certification

During the week of December 7, 2009, the New York State Citizen Election Modernization Advisory Committee met and reviewed certification test data results from the state’s testing program, and to vote on recommending approval of the two voting systems to the four Commissioners of the State Board of Election. The Commissioners will vote on final certification at their December 15, 2009 meeting. On December 10, 2009, the Advisory Committee approved recommendation by a vote of 10 For and 1 Against. I was the only vote opposing the recommendation. Below is the statement I made prior to the committee vote.

I believe in New York State’s certification process. It is rightfully called the best in the nation. We have required vendors to conform to a higher standard than ever before, we have conducted extensive testing with independent oversight, and as a result we have a huge trove of data upon which we can base our decision on whether these new voting systems are ready to be certified. Just the fact that we even have this substantial set of test results against a large number of very specific standards is a credit to New York’s process. Arguably, we have more data available to us about these systems than has ever been made available to a public body such this Advisory Committee before. It is because of this comprehensive approach that we can even be talking about some of the test findings, which never would have been revealed in a typical voting system certification program.

The Voting News Daily: Next Hawaii election a slow-moving train wreck? MOVE to expedite troop ballots free, Election Center ponders e-voting

The Election Center, a group that promoted the use of paperless voting, will meet Jan 7 & 8 to discuss voter reg, provisional ballots, and “the continued push to eliminate or restrict use of DREs” (The Election Center is a group that advises election officials while accepting donations from voting vendors)…Voter Action letter to Senate Rules committee about ES&S’s purchase of Diebold: “With this acquisition, ES&S has even less of an incentive to respond to the growing demand for improved accountability and product reliability.”…

Did you know that the MOVE act guarantees free expedited mail service to return troops’ ballots?…Hawaii Uh-OH: “This (upcoming election) is a slow-moving train wreck and we’re still far enough away that we can get everything off the track,” says attorney Lance Collins. The state’s elections department is grossly underfunded, considering cutting polling places in half, and is in process of making new election rules: Bob Babson hopes rules will ban sending any election results via the Internet or telephone lines…Learn more about Tennessee’s proposed voting machines…

All this and more in today’s voting news below…..

CA: Voter ID intiative backers get green light in California
Dec 10, 2009 – Backers of an initiative that would require voters to produce identification at the polls were given approval to begin gathering signatures Tuesday by Secretary of State Debra Bowen.
http://www.presstelegram.com/breakingnews/ci_13959475

CA: Council votes to delay decision on ranked-choice voting
12/09/2009
SAN LEANDRO — The City Council has delayed a decision on whether to use ranked-choice voting in its 2010 elections until Oakland decides if it will hold a similar ranked-choice election next year — giving San Leandro more time to explore ways to mitigate the costs of such an election.
http://www.insidebayarea.com/oaklandtribune/localnews/ci_13955369

GA: Oops: Group charging voting fraud admits mistake
“I acknowledge we had a huge misunderstanding about the data we were working with,” said Erica Long, co-chair of Citizens for Fair Atlanta Elections. “I would not have raised the issue with the Secretary of State if I did not believe it was correct.”
http://www.ajc.com/news/atlanta/oops-group-charging-voting-234563.html

HI: State proposes major revision of election rules
Dec 10, 2009 …Circuit Judge Joseph Cardoza decided that the state needs to hold a public hearing to come up with administrative rules governing electronic voting before new voting machines can be used in next year’s elections.

Written testimony can be e-mailed to elections@hawaii.gov or faxed to 453-6006. Written testimony will be accepted for the next two days.

“This (upcoming election) is a slow-moving train wreck and we’re still far enough away that we can get everything off the track,” Collins said.

Bob Babson, the lead plaintiff in the Maui lawsuit, said he is opposed to sending any election results via the Internet or telephone lines.

“It’s not secure,” Babson said. “They could easily just put it on a jet and fly it over.”
http://www.starbulletin.com/news/hawaiinews/20091210_
state_proposes_major_revision_of_election_rules.html
or use this url http://bit.ly/6tvKZz

Il: County to follow law on voting issue (machine notify voters of undervote in certain contests)
Iroquois County Clerk Lisa Fancher said she wants voters prepared for a new change in the election equipment.